Events   About   Projects   Experiments   Texts   Blogs   Resources   Contact horizontal divider horizontal divider horizontal divider
SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY SPEED DEBATE
07 Aug 2012; Laura Cinti - 10 Aug 2012

Following in venacular from its previous debate Synthetic Biology: Machine or Life? (UCL iGEM 2011) at the Science Museum's Dana Centre, a diverse audience had again gathered for the UCL iGEM 2012 debate: Synthetic Biology: Speed Debating aimed at a more intimate and interactive conversation on the topic of releasing genetically engineered organisms to clean up plastic pollution in the pacific ocean.


Plastic Sea. Photo Source: Coastal wiki

This year, the project - PLASTIC REPUBLIC - proposes to tackle plastic pollution in the ocean through bioremediation, engineering bacteria to clump together increasingly bigger bits of plastic to form artificial islands.

The speed debate evening provided an opportunity to discuss whether plastic pollution should be tackled by genetically modified organisms.  

Bethan Wolfenden (UCL iGEM 2012) introduced the event and welcomed the audience and the panel - Howard Boland (C-LAB), James Rutley and Erin Oerton (UCL iGEM).

Howard gave an overview and introduction to synthetic biology and iGEM (International Genetically Engineered Machine competition) leading up to the idea of PLASTIC REPUBLIC, which was explained by James.

The format of the evening, as outlined by Erin, introduced four questions that were each speed-tackled in 8-minutes followed by re-shuffling of participants. 

The questions: 

1. Should amateur scientists, ranging from garage biologists to iGEM teams, ever be allowed to create synthetic organisms?

2. Where scientific resources are limited, should we take action to tackle the symptoms of pollution or should we focus on tackling the root cause?

3. How far do we take into account public opinion, and do we still proceed if there is still informed dissent?

4. Should synthetic organisms ever be released into the ocean?


1. Plastic pollution inducing deformities in organisms 2. Midway atoll, bird corpse. Photo: Chris Jordan 3. Plastic found in Rainbow Runner fish guts. Photo Source: Algalita Marine Research Foundation. 4. Seal trapped in plastic pollution. Photo: Tedxgp2

I think I took the first two questions a bit too seriously and ended up in a heated debate on the question of tackling the root or the symptoms.  The project, inevitably, raises questions of potentially solving one problem (plastic pollution) but producing another (releasing of genetically engineered organisms into the ocean) - a catch-22.  

Phillip Boeing and Howard discussing the event and the biohacking proposal of producing the first publically created BioBrick™. 

Following the speed debating session,  the Q&A  sought to unpick up some of the discussions by probing into the questions further, such as: When do we consider something critical enough to use this sort of technology; Why do we consider it more appropriate to use such means (GMO) in dealing with nuclear pollution versus plastic; and how do we engineer this system with a safety net and can it be trusted?  

A great variety of people engaged in the debate and it was particlarly fascinating to listen to the many different and heartfelt perspectives.  

The videos below provide a brief introduction to the UCL iGEM 2012 project. 

See more photos of the PLASTIC REPUBLIC speed debating event here or via UCL iGEM's Fabecook page

Other References: http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2012-07/18/nanobots-recycling-plastic
Students synthesizing bacteria to create islands out of garbage
Synthetic Bacteria Could Turn Ocean Garbage into One Big Island
C-LAB:blog: Gene machine takes the prize
C-LAB:blog: KatE in a Jar
C-LAB:blog: London Hackspace at UCL Cruciform Lab
C-LAB:blog: Right or Risk? Preparation at London Hackspace
C-LAB:blog: Synthetic Biology, Creating ring pattern in a lawn of bacteria
C-LAB:blog: Synthetic Biology, Programmed Population Control
C-LAB:blog: Synthetic Life - getting serious about genetic engineering
C-LAB:blog: The Gibson Assembly Song
C-LAB:blog: Tic toc goes the bacteria clock
C-LAB:blog: Visiting London Hackspace with UCL iGEM
C-LAB:blog: Visiting the Grant Museum of Zoology
C-LAB:event: BIO ART WORKSHOP
C-LAB:event: CAGE RATTLING #1: KILL SWITCH
C-LAB:event: RE-NEW DIGITAL ARTS FESTIVAL
C-LAB:event: RIGHT OR RISK? WORLD'S FIRST PUBLIC BIOBRICK
C-LAB:event: SPEED DEBATE ON SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY AND NEURO-ETHICS
C-LAB:event: SYNTHESIS: SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY IN ART & SOCIETY
C-LAB:event: SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY SOCIETY KICK OFF EVENT
C-LAB:event: SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY SPEED DEBATE
C-LAB:event: SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY WORKSHOP
C-LAB:event: SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY: MACHINE OR LIFE?
Dana Centre: Synthetic Biology: Machine or Life?
London Science Festival: Synthetic Biology: Machine or Life?
Post Comment:
 
Name (required)  
Email (required - not displayed) 
Website

Letter 3 and 7 in the word above (required)  
To:
 
From:
 
Recent Events
EVAPORATION OF THINGS 13 13-14 Mar 2013 Inspace, Edinburgh, Scotland
DESIGNERS & ARTISTS 4 GENOMICS AWARD CEREMONY 06 Dec 2012 Naturalis Biodiversity Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands
MUTAMORPHOSIS: TRIBUTE TO UNCERTAINTY 06 06-08 Dec 2012 New Stage of the National Theatre & Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic
SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY SOCIETY KICK OFF EVENT 03 Dec 2012 Bentham B01 Main Lecture Theatre, UCL, London, UK
RE-NEW DIGITAL ARTS FESTIVAL 19 19-22 Nov 2012 Aalborg University, Copenhagen, Denmark
CAGE RATTLING #1: KILL SWITCH 29 Oct 2012 Kings Place, London, UK
RIGHT OR RISK? WORLD'S FIRST PUBLIC BIOBRICK 24 Sep 2012 Grant Museum of Zoology, London, UK
SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY SPEED DEBATE 07 Aug 2012 Richard Mully Basement Bar Lewis Building, UCL, London, UK
GRADUATE SCHOOL LAUNCH 21 Jun 2012 University of Westminster, London, UK
ARTISTS IN LABORATORIES 04 04-07 Jun 2012 Resonance 104.4 FM, London, UK
SUBTLE TECHNOLOGIES 24 24-27 May 2012 Ryerson University, Toronto, Canada
THE TWO CULTURES: VISUAL ART AND THE SCIENCES C.1800-2011 26 Apr 2012 Bowland Lecture Theatre, University of York, UK
C-LAB PREMIERS LIVING SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY WORKS AT TECHFEST 2012 02 02-08 Jan 2012 IIT Bombay, Mumbai, India
ANTÓNIO CARAMELO'S DREAMING OF A BUTTERFLY 04 Nov-31 Jan 2012 Bishop's Square, Spitalfields, London, UK
SYNTHETIC BIOLOGY: MACHINE OR LIFE? 20 Oct 2011 Dana Centre, Science Museum, London, UK
ANNE BRODIE'S BEE BOX 01 Sep-01 Nov 2011 Bishop's Square, Spitalfields, London, UK
© 2013 c-lab. All Rights Reserved. Sitemap | T&Cs | t: +31 (0)20 754 7207 e: info@c-lab.co.uk Design and Implementation by c-lab (2013)